DETROIT, Mich. (Michigan News Source) — Detroit’s VA Medical Center was caught polishing peer-review ratings to make bad surgical outcomes look routine. Now Democratic U.S. Sen. Gary Peters of Michigan wants a law that stops insiders from rewriting their own report cards.

Peters’ VA Peer Neutrality Act returns in direct response to a 2022 inquiry that found officials at Detroit’s John D. Dingell VA Medical Center altered external peer reviews in ways that hid ongoing concerns about surgical quality.

MORE NEWS: Michigan Home Values Thriving In Post Pandemic World

Investigators found cases downgraded from serious “Level 3” ratings—signaling care that fell outside what competent clinicians would do—to routine “Level 1” designations 11 times for a single provider.

The VA’s Office of the Medical Inspector called the tampering “a pattern of substandard care” stretching over at least two years. A follow-up review requested by Peters raised fresh doubts about whether the Midtown Detroit facility ever fixed the problem.

Peters’ bill would require that any VA staff member with a conflict of interest, including those involved in the underlying case, be barred from sitting on peer-review committees. Reviews involving committee members themselves would have to be sent to a neutral VA facility for a final determination.

The proposal is co-sponsored by Michigan’s other U.S. Senator Elissa Slotkin (D) and Sen. John Boozman (R-Ark.).

The misconduct previously led to the removal of several top officials at the Detroit VA, including its medical director in 2023.