ROCHESTER, Mich. (Michigan News Source) – In Rochester, Michigan, you can fly an American flag year-round, advertise your house for sale for months and display certain other signs without worrying about the calendar. But keep a Trump sign in your front yard too long, and City Hall might come knocking.
That’s what happened to Rochester resident Matthew Peterson, who received a November 5 notice from the city informing him that his Trump sign had overstayed its welcome.
MORE NEWS: Flags Lowered for Former Michigan Lawmaker Who Died After Bicycle Struck Sewer Pipe
Now Peterson has an attorney involved, and what started as a disagreement over a yard sign could become a constitutional showdown over free speech.
Apparently, Free Speech Has a 60-Day Expiration Date
According to the city’s Notice of Non-Compliance, temporary signs can be displayed for only one 60- day period per calendar year. Peterson was instructed to correct the violation within 10 days or risk further enforcement action.
The offending sign? A photograph of President Donald Trump raising his fist after surviving the July 13, 2024, assassination attempt in Butler, Pennsylvania, with the word “TRUMP” underneath. The sign also says “Paid for by the property owner.”
No profanity. No threats. No flashing lights. It’s not even a campaign sign. It’s just a picture of the president on a sign sitting in a flower bed beside Peterson’s front porch, well back from the street. But evidently, that’s enough to get the attention of Rochester’s code enforcement department. The notice they sent him said that he was receiving it as a result of an inspection of his property or in response to a complaint. Chances are, it was a complaint that prompted the inspection, considering the sign had reportedly been sitting there since shortly after the assassination attempt on Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania, in July 2024.
Attorney Says the Constitution Doesn’t Come With a Stopwatch
On November 18, attorney Kevin Kijewski of KDK Law, representing Peterson, fired back with a three-page letter to Rochester Code Enforcement Officer David Bisby, City Manager Nik Banda and City Attorney Jeffrey Kragt. Kijewski argues that the city’s 60-day restriction violates the First Amendment and cites multiple court decisions involving restrictions on residential signs.
Among them is a 1985 Michigan Court of Appeals decision striking down a similar 60-day sign restriction in Wyoming, Michigan.
MORE NEWS: President Trump Offers Delay on Medicaid Work Requirements, State Reviewing New Guidance
Kijewski also cites two U.S. Supreme Court decisions. In City of Ladue v. Gilleo (1994), the justices unanimously struck down a Missouri ordinance prohibiting most residential signs, recognizing the importance of homeowners’ First Amendment rights. In Reed v. Town of Gilbert (2015), the Court ruled that sign regulations treating messages differently based on their content are subject to strict constitutional scrutiny. Both decisions are relevant to Peterson’s situation because Rochester limits most temporary signs to 60 days while allowing certain other signs to remain longer. Kijewski also argues that Peterson’s Trump sign doesn’t advertise a candidacy or election, raising questions about why the city classified it as a “political candidate sign” in the first place. He also points out that the city raises no problems with the sign’s size, height, placement or condition.
Kijewski states in his letter that Rochester’s ordinance treats different types of signs differently. A real estate sign can remain up without a specified time limit. Garage sale signs get 12 days. Certain development signs can remain for two years. Governmental flags can fly indefinitely. But a homeowner displaying a political message? Sixty days, according to the city’s notice.
For Kijewski, the issue isn’t just about how long a sign can remain in someone’s yard. It’s about whether city officials can put an expiration date on political expression. As he puts it, “A homeowner’s support for the president does not expire on the City’s calendar.”
Could a Trump Sign Land Someone in Jail?
Here’s where things get particularly interesting. According to Kijewski, Rochester’s zoning ordinance classifies violations as misdemeanors punishable by fines of up to $500, up to 90 days in jail, or both. Each day a violation continues can constitute a separate offense. That doesn’t mean Peterson is headed to jail over his Trump sign. No criminal charge has been reported – yet. But his attorney argues that the ordinance makes criminal penalties a possibility. In a statement to Michigan News Source, Kijewski says, “Rochester’s ordinance puts jail on the table for a man who put a sign next to his own front porch.”
City Hall Has Until November 23 to Respond
Peterson’s attorney is demanding that Rochester withdraw its notice and confirm in writing that it won’t pursue enforcement over the sign. The deadline is 5 p.m. Monday, November 23.
Kijewski has also requested preservation of records related to the complaint and enforcement action and says he is submitting a Freedom of Information Act request. If the city refuses to withdraw its complaint against Peterson, Kijewski says that his client is prepared to challenge the ordinance in court, potentially seeking damages and attorney fees.
Does Free Speech Depend on the Message?
For now, the dispute raises many questions: If homeowners can’t display a political opinion or support of a politician or an issue on their own property without watching the calendar, exactly how free is that speech?
It also raises another important and related question: Are there “Black Lives Matter” signs or LGBTQ pride flags in the same neighborhood that have been displayed for months, or even years, without attracting the attention of code enforcement? After all, political and ideological displays are hardly unusual in many communities. So is Rochester applying its sign ordinances equally to everyone, regardless of the political message being displayed? And do they only send out notices when there is a complaint?
And Rochester certainly isn’t the only Michigan community where homeowners use their property to make political or ideological statements. Just look at downtown Traverse City, a very liberal city, where signs promoting various causes are a common sight on private property. One homeowner has even painted Pride colors and messages across a fence bordering the road.
Is a Trump Sign Worth a Taxpayer-Funded Legal Battle?
Perhaps a more practical question for Rochester taxpayers: Is fighting over a Trump sign really worth a potentially expensive First Amendment lawsuit?
Michigan News Source contacted all three individuals named in the attorney’s response, but none had responded to our request for comment by press time.
