LANSING, Mich. (Michigan News Source) – Michigan’s open primary system is fueling an unusual debate among some Republican voters: Should they cast a ballot in the Democratic primary instead of their own?

With President Donald Trump’s endorsement giving U.S. Rep. John James a boost in the Republican gubernatorial race, some grassroots conservatives are openly discussing whether it’s worth crossing over into the Democratic primary instead – but not because they’ve suddenly become Democrats. The reasons vary: some want a say about which Democratic U.S. Senate and gubernatorial candidate Republicans will face in November, while others simply aren’t enthusiastic about the Republican primary choices.

Operation Chaos: an old political playbook.

MORE NEWS: Sherrone Moore’s Former Girlfriend Sues U-M Over $12 Million Investigation Records

The idea isn’t exactly new. It’s a modern version of “Operation Chaos,” the strategy popularized years ago by late conservative radio host Rush Limbaugh. The concept is simple: if your own party’s primary isn’t competitive, if you have no favorite, or your preferred candidate appears to be out of the running – vote in the other party’s primary to influence its outcome.

During the 2008 presidential primary, Limbaugh encouraged Republican voters in states with open primaries to vote in the Democratic primary, arguing that doing so could prolong the closely contested race between Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton, force Democrats to spend more time and money battling one another, and potentially leave the eventual nominee weakened for the general election. The strategy was controversial, but it became one of the best-known examples of crossover voting as a political tactic.

A Facebook debate with more than 100 comments.

The strategy of doing an Operation Chaos in Michigan’s August primary has been discussed on social media and between Republicans for a while now. The discussion recently surfaced in the public Facebook group Michigan – MAGA – America First – People’s Grassroots Campaign, which has more than 20,000 members.

Brian Frank, who posted the Operation Chaos idea in the Facebook group, urged fellow Republicans to consider voting in the Democratic primary instead of the GOP contest. Before former state Sen. Mallory McMorrow suspended her U.S. Senate campaign, Frank encouraged Republicans to back her for Senate and Genesee County Sheriff Chris Swanson for governor and who is running against Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson.

His reasoning was simple: if Republican voters believe U.S. Rep. John James has essentially locked up the GOP gubernatorial nomination, why not use their votes to influence the Democratic field instead? His strategy, he argued, could help prevent Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson, former state health director Abdul El-Sayed, and U.S. Rep. Haley Stevens from advancing to the November ballot.

Polling numbers.

Frank’s strategy depends on a few key assumptions that would motivate Republican voters to cross over: that the Republican gubernatorial primary is already largely decided and that the voter has no local races they need to cast a ballot in.

A new internal poll (June 28-30) conducted by OnMessage Inc. for the John James campaign shows James holding a commanding lead in the GOP gubernatorial primary, with 46% support, followed by businessman Perry Johnson at 21% and former Attorney General Mike Cox at 14%.

MORE NEWS: Bickering Overshadows Policy in First GOP Governor Debate

Frank told Michigan News Source, “If this poll is accurate, James is going to be the nominee. Since everyone else on my ballot is running unopposed, why not try and take out Benson and El-Sayed?”

Operation Chaos post sparks debate inside Republican ranks.

Frank’s post about doing an Operation Chaos in Michigan generated more than 100 comments, with opinions scattered across the political map. Some embraced the idea. Others wanted nothing to do with it.

One commenter said voting for any Democrat was a bridge too far. Another argued Republicans should trust Trump’s endorsement and avoid “playing games.” Several acknowledged they aren’t enthusiastic about James but still planned to vote Republican because defeating Democrats in November remained their priority.

Not everyone is sold on the GOP field though.

The discussion highlighted a reality that has simmered beneath the surface of Michigan politics for months: not every Republican is thrilled with the party’s candidates for governor.

Some commenters said they preferred Perry Johnson or Mike Cox and expressed frustration with James. Some indicated they actually liked Swanson better than the entire Republican field. Online chatter in the MAGA Facebook group and elsewhere suggests at least some conservatives are wrestling with how to cast their votes in a way they believe will best serve Michigan and maximize Republican chances in November.

Political strategy – or political mischief?

Operation Chaos has always been controversial, even among Republicans. Supporters see it as strategic politics played under the rules of Michigan’s open primary system. Critics argue voters should simply choose the nominee they genuinely support instead of trying to influence the other party’s race.

Of course, even the would-be Operation Chaos crowd can’t agree on the strategy. They’re divided over which Democrat would give Republicans the best chance in November. In the U.S. Senate race, for example, some argue that former health director Abdul El-Sayed’s strong support from progressives could make him a weaker general election candidate, believing his liberal positions may have less appeal to moderates and independent voters. Others just don’t want him on the ticket at all and are thinking about voting for Haley to help her beat him.

Operation Chaos? Michigan’s open primary makes it possible.

Asked about Operation Chaos and voters crossing over to participate in the opposing party’s primary, Patrice Johnson, Chairperson and Founder of MI Fair Elections, said that Michigan’s open primary system allows voters to choose either party’s ballot because the state does not require voters to declare a party affiliation.

In her personal opinion – not on behalf of the group – she called that a weakness of the current system, saying she has seen Republicans vote in Democratic primaries and Democrats vote in Republican primaries, including during President Trump’s campaigns. She said she would prefer Michigan require voters to declare a party and vote only in that party’s primary, adding that people who are uncomfortable declaring a party “shouldn’t sabotage the other side.” She also suggested concerned citizens contact their legislators about changing the law.

Whether “Michigan Operation Chaos” remains mostly internet chatter or turns into actual crossover votes is anyone’s guess. But the conversation itself reveals something noteworthy: not every Michigan Republican is satisfied with the choices on their own ballot, and some are already looking across the aisle – not to switch parties, but to play political chess with the Democrats’ lineup.